Pervasive Shallowness in Java

Java, a widely used object-oriented programming language, is renowned for its versatility, portability, and robustness. One of the essential concepts in Java programming is the notion of object copying and equality checking. However, beneath its seemingly straightforward façade lies a nuanced concept known as "shallow copy" and "shallow equality." These concepts, while appearing simple, can lead to subtle bugs and unexpected behaviors if not fully understood.

The Shallow Copy Dilemma

In Java, objects are stored in memory, and variables often reference these objects rather than holding the objects themselves. A copy of an object, when created, can be either a "shallow copy" or a "deep copy." Shallow copies replicate only the references to the original object's fields, while deep copies create entirely new instances of all nested objects as well.

ShallowCopyExample.java

import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.List;
class Student {
    String name;
    List<String> courses;
    // Constructor and methods...
    public Student shallowCopy() {
        Student copy = new Student();
        copy.name = this.name;
        copy.courses = this.courses; // Shallow copy of the List
        return copy;
    }
}
public class ShallowCopyExample {
    public static void main(String[] args) {
        // Create a student
        Student originalStudent = new Student();
        originalStudent.name = "John";
        originalStudent.courses = new ArrayList<>();
        originalStudent.courses.add("Math");
        originalStudent.courses.add("Physics");
        // Perform a shallow copy
        Student copiedStudent = originalStudent.shallowCopy();
        // Modify the courses in the copied student
        copiedStudent.courses.add("Chemistry");
        // Print original and copied student courses
        System.out.println("Original student courses: " + originalStudent.courses);
        System.out.println("Copied student courses: " + copiedStudent.courses);
    }
}

Output:

Original student courses: [Math, Physics, Chemistry]
Copied student courses: [Math, Physics, Chemistry]

Explanation

In this example, if we perform a shallow copy of a Student object, changes made to the courses list in the copied object will also affect the original object. Because both objects share the same reference to the list in memory. It can lead to unintended side effects if not managed properly.

Serialization and Cloning

Serialization is the process of converting an object into a stream of bytes for storage or transmission. While serialization can create a deep copy of an object by writing it to a byte stream and then reading it back, it's important to note that this process might involve some complexities. Some objects might not be serializable, and serialized objects may require explicit handling for proper deserialization.

SerializationExample.java

import java.io.*;
class Student implements Serializable {
    String name;
}
public class SerializationExample {
    public static void main(String[] args) {
        // Create a student
        Student student = new Student();
        student.name = "Alice";
        // set other fields...
        // Serialization
        try {
            ByteArrayOutputStream byteArrayOutputStream = new ByteArrayOutputStream();
            ObjectOutputStream objectOutputStream = new ObjectOutputStream(byteArrayOutputStream);
            objectOutputStream.writeObject(student);
            objectOutputStream.close();
            byte[] byteArray = byteArrayOutputStream.toByteArray();
            // Deserialization
            ByteArrayInputStream byteArrayInputStream = new ByteArrayInputStream(byteArray);
            ObjectInputStream objectInputStream = new ObjectInputStream(byteArrayInputStream);
            Student deserializedStudent = (Student) objectInputStream.readObject();
            objectInputStream.close();
            // Print deserialized student details
            System.out.println("Deserialized student name: " + deserializedStudent.name);
            // print other fields...
        } catch (IOException | ClassNotFoundException e) {
            e.printStackTrace();
        }
    }
} 

Output:

Deserialized student name: Alice

Java Collections and Shallow Copy

Java's standard library includes various collections like ArrayList, HashMap, etc. When dealing with these collections, it's essential to understand their behavior regarding shallow copying.

List<Student> originalList = new ArrayList<>();
originalList.add(student1);
// Shallow copy of the list
List<Student> copiedList = new ArrayList<>(originalList);

Unravelling Shallow Equality

Shallow equality, on the other hand, is the comparison of object references rather than their content. Two objects are considered shallowly equal if they reference the same memory address. This can sometimes lead to confusion, especially when working with collections and arrays.

ShallowEqualityExample.java

class Student {
    String name;
}
public class ShallowEqualityExample {
    public static void main(String[] args) {
        // Create two students with the same content
        Student student1 = new Student();
        student1.name = "Alice";
        // set other fields...
        Student student2 = new Student();
        student2.name = "Alice";
        // set other fields...
        // Shallow equality check
        if (student1 == student2) {
            System.out.println("Students are shallowly equal.");
        } else {
            System.out.println("Students are not shallowly equal.");
        }
    }
}

Output:

Students are not shallowly equal.

Explanation

In this example, student1 and student2 are not the same object instances, so they are not shallowly equal, despite having the same field values.

The Consequences and Mitigations

Pervasive shallowness in Java can result in unexpected behaviors, such as unintended modifications, incorrect comparisons, and inefficient memory usage. To address these challenges, consider the following strategies:

Use Deep Copy When Needed: If you want to create truly independent copies of objects and their nested structures, consider implementing deep copy mechanisms. This ensures that changes made to copied objects do not affect the original ones.
Override equals Method: When dealing with object equality checks, consider overriding the equals method to define custom equality based on the object's content rather than its reference. This approach provides more control over how objects are compared.
Immutable Objects: Designing classes with immutable properties can help mitigate the effects of shallow copying and equality. Immutable objects are inherently resistant to unintentional modifications.
Defensive Copying: When assigning object references from one object to another, consider performing defensive copying to ensure that the copied object cannot be modified externally.

Conclusion

The concept of shallow copying and shallow equality in Java might appear simple on the surface, but it holds significant implications for the behavior and correctness of the code. To avoid bugs and unexpected outcomes, developers must be conscious of the differences between shallow and deep copies, as well as the distinctions between shallow and content-based equality. By understanding these nuances and employing defensive programming techniques, Java programmers can navigate the landscape of pervasive shallowness with confidence and precision.

Next TopicSequenced Collections in Java 21

← prev next →