Shall I Compare Thee To The Summer's Day Summary

About Author

William Shakespeare, born in 1564 in Stratford upon Avon, was a highly accomplished playwright, actor, and revered poet. He is widely regarded as one of the most prominent figures in English literature. Throughout his career, Shakespeare composed a remarkable collection of 37 plays, encompassing a range of genres such as comedies, histories, and tragedies. Additionally, he crafted 154 sonnets, with two of them being translations of Greek epigrams.

Among these sonnets, Sonnet 18 stands as one of his most beloved works. It belongs to the initial series of Shakespearean sonnets, numbered 1-126, which are dedicated to a "Fair Youth." This "Fair Youth" refers to a young nobleman who held a special place in the poet's heart, evoking deep feelings of love and admiration. The subsequent sonnets (numbered 126-152) were dedicated to the "Dark Lady."

According to scholars, the "Dark Lady" is depicted as a woman who is physically unattractive but possesses a strong sexual allure that captivates the poet, leading him to develop intense feelings for her. Throughout the sonnets, the poet finds himself entangled in a complex interplay of love and aggression, especially when a third party becomes involved.

The authenticity of Sonnet 18 and Shakespeare's other sonnets as true experiences or works of fiction is still a subject of debate. In the Online Encyclopaedia Encarta, it is suggested that while scholars have attempted to identify specific individuals addressed in the sonnets, it is unlikely that they are strictly personal. Instead, it is believed that the sonnets provided Shakespeare with a structured platform for experimenting with lyric verse, allowing him to play with established conventions of emotion and poetry.

In conclusion, William Shakespeare's contribution to literature as a playwright, actor, and poet is unparalleled. His collection of sonnets, including the celebrated Sonnet 18, showcases his mastery of poetic expression and explores themes of love, beauty, and the complexities of human relationships. While the exact personal significance of these sonnets remains a mystery, their enduring appeal lies in their artistic brilliance and the universality of the emotions they evoke.

Introduction

Sonnet 18 holds a significant position within Shakespeare's sonnet sequence and is widely recognized as one of the most renowned lyric poems in the English language. While it may not necessarily be deemed the best or most captivating sonnet, its enduring popularity stems from the simplicity and beauty with which it extols the virtues of the beloved. Among Shakespeare's works, only iconic lines like "To be or not to be" and "Romeo, Romeo, wherefore art thou Romeo?" rival its fame.

The reasons for the sonnet's widespread appeal can vary, but one undeniable factor is the special atmosphere created by William Shakespeare. He skillfully compares his profound and boundless love to the exquisite splendor of a summer's day, setting a captivating tone right from the opening line ("Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?"). The enchanting imagery and the timeless themes of love and beauty further contribute to its enduring popularity.

Summary

Sonnet 18 is primarily a love poem, although the nature of the speaker's affection is not as straightforward as it may initially appear. The speaker begins by attempting to find an appropriate metaphor to describe their beloved, who is traditionally believed to be a young man. Various comparisons are suggested, such as likening the beloved to a summer's day, the sun, or the budding flowers of May. However, the speaker quickly dismisses each metaphor, realizing that they fall short of capturing the true essence of the beloved's beauty. These comparisons imply the inevitability of decline and death.

As the poem progresses, the speaker's objections shift. Rather than asserting the superiority of the beloved over the metaphors, the speaker recognizes the darker implications within the suggested comparisons. The seasonal references imply impermanence and the passage of time. The speaker acknowledges that the young man's beauty is not subject to decay or change. The conventional metaphors fail to convey the everlasting quality of the beloved's beauty. Instead, the speaker proposes that the true comparison lies within the poem itself.

The poem is presented as a reflection of the eternal beauty possessed by the young man. While previous metaphors have proven inadequate, the speaker argues that the lines of the poem are everlasting, just like the young man's beauty. In a circular motion, the poem becomes the very embodiment of the beloved's eternal qualities. The speaker suggests that it is through the poem that the young man's beauty is both reflected and preserved.

Going beyond a simple metaphor, the speaker advances a more ambitious claim: the poem grants the young man eternal life. The poem's assertion becomes circular, as the young man's beauty is not like a fleeting summer's day or a transitory sun. Instead, it attains a form of permanence and immortality through the praises sung within the poem itself. The speaker believes that poems possess an inherent power, capable of transcending time and preserving the beauty they describe. Poetry is portrayed as a means to eternal life, a testament to the enduring nature of the young man's beauty.

Ultimately, the poem prompts readers to contemplate the intrinsic power of poetry. It invites reflection on how poetry defies the grasp of time, how it can protect against the inevitable decay of life, and how it serves as a vessel for preserving and creating beauty that surpasses the fleeting nature of the mortal world.

Analysis

This particular sonnet undoubtedly holds the distinction of being the most renowned within Shakespeare's sonnet sequence, and it may even be considered the most famous lyric poem in the English language. While other lines such as "To be or not to be" and "Romeo, Romeo, wherefore art thou Romeo?" from Shakespeare's works enjoy widespread recognition, Sonnet 18 stands out. It is important to note, however, that its popularity does not necessarily indicate it as the best, most intriguing, or most exquisite of the sonnets. Rather, it is cherished for its simplicity and the endearing praise it bestows upon the beloved.

At first glance, the poem appears to be a straightforward expression of admiration for the beloved's beauty. It draws a contrast between the harsh extremes of summer, marked by excessive heat and gusty winds, and the beloved, who remains consistently gentle and moderate. The personification of summer as the "eye of heaven" with a "gold complexion" is merely incidental.

The imagery employed throughout the poem is unadorned and unpretentious, with the transition from the delightful buds of May to the promise of an "eternal summer" for the beloved. The language employed is also comparatively plain for a sonnet, devoid of excessive alliteration or assonance. Each line functions as a self-contained clause, often concluding with punctuation that creates deliberate pauses.

Notably, Sonnet 18 departs from its predecessors by not explicitly urging the young man to procreate. The "procreation" sequence, encompassing the first 17 sonnets, concludes with the speaker's realization that the young man's beauty can endure without the need for offspring. Instead, the speaker suggests that beauty can live on within the speaker's rhymes. Sonnet 18 serves as the initial embodiment of this "rhyme," the speaker's initial attempt to immortalize the young man's beauty for eternity.

A recurring theme within the sonnet sequence, and particularly prominent in this poem, is the power of the speaker's verse to defy the constraints of time and preserve the beauty of the beloved for future generations. The beloved's "eternal summer" shall never fade precisely because it is encapsulated within the sonnet itself. In the concluding couplet, the speaker asserts, "So long as men can breathe or eyes can see, / So long lives this, and this gives life to thee."